You must be logged in to post Login

Search Forums:


 






Post Exercise Nutrition on a Low Calorie, Low Carb Diet?

UserPost

10:49 am
January 6, 2010


CodeMonkey

Roswell, GA

Member

posts 40


My wife wants to start the "Take Shape for Life" diet, using Medifast products.  (I've googled it a lot, and can't find any negative publicity).  It's a low carb diet, recommended by doctors, yatta yatta.  Anyway, since she's in, I'm in.  It will be nice to do something together!


But, I think it will be tough to keep up my existing workout regimen.  I was thinking of trying to keep it (roughly 500kcals a day of exercise), but, I'll need to supplement the diet with more calories to compensate.  Perfect time for post exercise nutrition!


But, then there's the crowbar.  This diet seems to be a low carb one.  And, drinking a Surge Recovery will give me 45g of carbs :)  Our "Health Coach" has ok'ed Muscle Milk (non light) at 12 grams.  But, I really want the amino acids, etc.  So, I thought I'd come here for suggestions.


What would be some good choices for post exercise nutrition, while keeping the carbs to < 15 or so?  (Maybe one scoop of Surge?)


-Dave

In the paraphrased words of Socrates, "I ate what?"

12:54 pm
January 6, 2010


Paul

Member

posts 38

Well, I'm presuming you want 500 calories to balance out the ones you're burning and you don't want any carbs if possible.


So, I'm thinking a 6 oz steak.

1:37 pm
January 6, 2010


CodeMonkey

Roswell, GA

Member

posts 40


hehe


I really don't know what I *should* do.  The current "wisdom" on post workout nutrition is to eat carbs / protein in a 4:1 ratio.  And, not to make up the complete caloric deficit, but make up some of it, so that your muscles have "food".


But, I'm not sure what percentage of the calories burned I should eat, or, what I should eat for the 4 in the 4:1 ratio.

In the paraphrased words of Socrates, "I ate what?"

3:00 pm
January 6, 2010


Michael C. McGreevy

Admin

posts 60

I'm confused.  According to the web site for the Medifast plan there is no carb counting.  I quote…

You don't have to count points, calories or carbs. You simply eat every two to three hours, for a total of 5 Medifast Meals and 1 Lean & Green Meal (a serving of lean meat or protein plus low-carbohydrate vegetables) each day.

Source

That being the case why don't you just have your "Lean and Green" meal after you workout?

3:23 pm
January 6, 2010


CodeMonkey

Roswell, GA

Member

posts 40


I'm just being anal.  Their FAQ's say to cut your workouts in half when starting the plan, due to the caloric reduction.


They also say no more than 45 mins a day.


I'm trying to keep my 45 a day, to avoid getting sore again, if I drop the strength training.  I guess, technically, 45 3 days a week . . .but I digress.


That's a good adea about the lean and green meal.

In the paraphrased words of Socrates, "I ate what?"

3:29 pm
January 6, 2010


Rafe Brox

Shrink Geek Orbital HQ (Weight Room)

Admin

posts 43

I'm with Mike on this. The program itself just seems to want you to eat sensibly, not omit carbs altogether.

If you want to buff the Muscle Milk with some amino acids, you could always get some BCAA (branched chain amino acid) powder to mix with it, or get it in capsule/pill form and pop a couple of them with your post-workout shake.  Note: BCAA powder tastes fairly bitter and awful, and you need to shake really well to get it thoroughly dissolved..

Replenishing muscle glycogen stores immediately after exercise, along with a dose of protein, is the recipe for muscle growth (if that is what you're after). If weight loss is your primary concern, a smaller carb footprint after exercise should be fine.

If you're burning more than you're eating, you'll lose weight.

The laws of physics and thermodynamics do not care what you eat.

This is only a test.

4:02 pm
January 6, 2010


Michael C. McGreevy

Admin

posts 60

I just found the bit about exercising.  You'll have to pardon me if I look with a certain amount of Spock-like raised eyebrows on any diet that tells you to exercise less.

4:13 pm
January 6, 2010


CodeMonkey

Roswell, GA

Member

posts 40


But, 1000 calories is SOOOO low that I do understand it.  There's creating a caloric deficit, and then there's insta-starvation mode.

In the paraphrased words of Socrates, "I ate what?"

4:38 pm
January 6, 2010


Michael C. McGreevy

Admin

posts 60

I think you've just made my point.

Starvation diets = bad.



About the ShrinkGeek forum

Currently Online:

7 Guests

Membership:

There are 132 Members

There has been 1 Guest

There are 3 Admins

There are 0 Moderators




Eat Until You're Full - Fullbar.com
© 2012 ShrinkGeek Suffusion theme by Sayontan Sinha